diglloyd
Max Your Mac Pro at OWC
Max Your Mac Pro at OWC
SSDHard drivesMemory
Mac Performance Guide
Zeiss Lenses
Zeiss Lenses
Our trusted photo rental store
Our trusted photo rental store

Nikon 70-200mm f/4G ED VR Testing Comments

My review of the Nikon 70-200mm f/4G ED VR is in progress.

On the Nikon D800E, a focus difference of about one inch at a distance of 35 feet determines which lens is best. As I saw today, a “miss” of 1 inch “proves” that the same lens is better than itself or worse than itself. Such are the problems in making a comparison with a 36-megapixel camera. I am pondering the best way to handle this.

Contrast detect AF is provably not up to the accuracy required (as I have seen many times with various lenses); I can and did do better today using manual focus (my eye with a loupe, Live View magnified).

At ƒ/2.8, the 70-200/2.8 is too low contrast with possible focus shift to deal with, so it must be focused at ƒ/4. But at ƒ/4 as with the 70-200/4, there is too much depth of field for unambiguous focus. Focus bracketing is one solution, and I do have an 18-inch rail, so this might be the tedious and time consuming approach necessary, but it only works for distances not too far. Otherwise, it might have to be distance-only comparisons, with several focusing attempts. Given the lack of a tripod collar for the 70-200/4, this might have to be the proper way to go, regrettably ruling out mid-range shots, which are arguable more relevant.

All that said, this test image (bike) is revealing of performance nonetheless, and so I think I will present it as an aperture series for sharpness.

Unrelated: some new shots with the Nikon D800E + Nikon AF-S 24mm f/1.4G are posted on my cycling site. I liked using the 24/1.4G for product shots; I correct for distortion and chromatic aberration and the fast autofocus is helpful.

Moots Psychlo X RSL with Shimano DuraAce Di2, FMB Paris Roubaix Pro tires Nikon D800E + 70-200/4G VR @ 175mm @ ƒ/8
Moots Psychlo X RSL with Shimano DuraAce Di2, FMB Paris Roubaix Pro tires
Nikon D800E + 70-200/4G VR @ 175mm @ ƒ/8

diglloyd Inc. | FTC Disclosure | PRIVACY POLICY | Trademarks | Terms of Use
Contact | About Lloyd Chambers | Consulting | Photo Tours
RSS Feeds | Twitter
Copyright © 2008-2015 diglloyd Inc, all rights reserved.