diglloyd

Digital Photo Professional Preview Inaccuracy

Introduction

Updated for DPP 3.0.2 on August 13, 2007.

Users of Canon’s Digital Photo Professional (DPP) should be aware that previewing an image displays a lower-quality version than the final processed version in actual-pixels view.

Even with the Operating Mode preference (see below) set to Quality Priority, Digital Photo Professional does not display the same quality image as the final processed image, making an assessment of the fine details of image quality problematic (within DPP).

The Operating Mode preference in Digital Photo Professional

This problem is present in version 2.0.3.7 of Digital Photo Professional. It might or might not be present in later versions.  Most likely it is present in earlier versions as well.

The inaccuracy appears to be limited to color aliasing.  Here is an example of the issue:

100% of actual pixels
As Processed
As Previewed
Operating Mode = Quality Priority

200% of actual pixels (for ease of viewing)
As Processed
As Previewed
Operating Mode = Quality Priority

Quality isn’t

Quite unexpectedly, setting the Operating Mode preference to Standard or Speed seems to improve things.  There does not appear to be any difference between Standard and Speed in this example.

100% of actual pixels, As Previewed in Digital Photo Professional
Operating Mode = Quality
Operating Mode = Standard
Operating Mode = Speed

Example with version 3.0.2

One might reasonably expect that by version 3 such problems would be fixed. Unfortunately, the problem looks just as bad, if not worse. This is with Viewing and saving RAW images = High Quality.

preview  preview
DPP 3.0.2 preview (left), as processed (right)

Such problems are particularly maddening when using EOS Utility to verify critical focus before taking a series of exposures (camera hooked to computer). The defective preview makes it harder to judge whether critical focus has been achieved, an ironic problem since the primary design goal of the Live View functionality is to verify critical focus.

Conclusions

Whether these results are peculiar to  every image, or just specific ones, has not been investigated.  Users of DPP should be aware of this issue if they are making judgments about the fine details of image quality.

Contact:    email diglloyd a comment on this article.

See also:
   diglloyd articles & reviews page | blog | photos

  You’ve just enjoyed a free digloyd.com article. Diglloyd.com also offers paid articles/reviews, whose depth and breadth you’ll rarely find anywhere else—and which you can rely on for purchasing decisions.
  Save yourself the aggravation and expense of buying the wrong equipment, and make the right choice for your photographic needs—get the reviews that analyze, inform, describe, and teach based on real-world experience, while providing detailed examples for you to make your own informed decisions.

na na na na na
Nikon D200 vs D2X Nikon D2X vs Canon EOS 5D & 1Ds Mark II Raw-file Converters The Sharpest Image 28mm Shfit Lenses